Let Amira Sing Opera, Hurrah!

The Caterpillar said Evidence is heard and seen that

a child, a Princess called Amira sang the opera aria

“O Mio Babbino Caro” - but in spite of the Evidence,

THIS Hypothesis was formulated by Opera Lovers:

.

All opera singers are grown-ups - therefore NO opera

singer can ever be a child, ERGO there simply must

be a Categorical Imperative formulated & stipulated:

NO child may ever sing an opera aria
.

This is a Verification Problem for Probability Theory: 

the Factor by which the Rational Degree of Belief in

the Hypothesis is enhanced by sensory Evidence 

of Amira singing opera arias and winning HGT -

.

Is found in the Ratio of Subjective Probabilities seen

by any rational person, but for them the connections 

between grown-ups, children and opera singers are

confusing and philosophy can’t unravel their

.

Misleading assumptions, therefore we conclude -

let Amira sing opera, hurrah!

.
[Debate with Opera Lovers showed they have a Hypothesis

contradicted by sensory Evidence, yet they are willing to

die for their cherished Hypothesis]